Lighthouse
During the dark, I kept my light on for you.
I waited, shining, for you to appear at sea.
I didn't know that you would sail right through.
During the day, I searched for your ship anew,
And worried if a storm had caused you to flee.
During the dark, I kept my light on for you.
Then I saw you on the ocean blue,
But your chosen course led away from me.
I didn't know that you would sail right through.
I watched as you steered me into your rearview,
As you turned me from guide into memory.
I didn't know that you would sail right through.
But there was nothing I could do.
Your voyage was yours, wherever it leads.
During the dark, I kept my light on for you.
And that would stay, if I'd known you'd sail right through.
01 — Form: One Tercet Short.
A villanelle has five tercets followed by a closing quatrain. This draft has only four tercets, disrupting the refrain and rhyme pattern which should be as follows: A1, b, A2; a, b, A1; a, b, A2; a, b, A1; a, b, A2; a, b, A1, A2.
02 — Pacing: Emotional Development.
The missing tercet is a chance to give the lighthouse one last action: a final attempt to reach the ship. If the reader sees this last effort, it makes the steering away in the next tercet hit harder. This also gives space to sit with that emotion before the ending.
03 — Imagery: Consistency and Concrete Imagery.
A few lines stay general where more detail would sharpen the lighthouse's point of view.
"Then I saw you on the ocean blue": what else could be added here to make this image feel more real? What does the ship look like? What about the state of the sea?
"Rearview" usually refers to vehicles. A neutral version of this such as "out of view" would work better.
04 — Metaphor: Subtext.
The central metaphor of this poem lies in how the lighthouse must remain stationary as the ship sails on. In the final quatrain, it is stated outright: "But there was nothing I could do." How can the reader be shown this instead? Consider traits of the lighthouse that might display that. For example, the only thing that can move in the lighthouse is its light. If you show a fight against that stillness, the refrains can take on new meaning and depth.
Lighthouse
During the dark, I kept my light on for you.
I waited, shining, for you to appear at sea.
I didn't know that you would sail right through.
During the day, I searched for your ship anew,
And worried if a storm had caused you to flee.
During the dark, I kept my light on for you.
Then I saw your hull rocking on the choppy blue,
But your chosen course led away from me.
I didn't know that you would sail right through.
I shined my beam and over the waves it flew,
But bright as it was, you didn't see.
During the dark, I kept my light on for you.
I watched as you steered me out of view,
As you turned me from guide into memory.
I didn't know that you would sail right through.
In stone I was rooted as the tide withdrew,
And only my lamp was free;
So, during the dark, I kept my light on for you.
And I'd keep it lit, had I known you'd sail right through.